Comment: I've been a long time user of Sebastian's Twisted Taffy and tried this as a substitute for Taffy. From this perspective I was disappointed. Mud lacked the hold and long-lasting effects of taffy. I found that the hold would expiry mid-day, leaving behind a residue which looked flaky and dry--quite unlike Taffy which would give that all-day wet look.
Please Sebastian, bring back Twisted Taffy!